MyFitnessPal vs Strava
“Which one wastes more of your one finite, irreplaceable life? We ran the numbers. We made the numbers up. The result is somehow still accurate.”
MyFitnessPal
“Open for a reason. Stay for no reason at all.”
Strava
“Turn a quiet jog into a public performance graded by people you barely know.”
| Feature | MyFitnessPal | Strava |
|---|---|---|
| 🕳️ Hours Wasted / Day | 6.8 hrs More hours = clear winner of nothing. | 1.5 hrs |
| 🔥 Lifetime Damage | 2M hrs | 636K hrs |
| Our Rating | 4.3 | 4.2 |
| App Store | ||
| Google Play | 4.4 | 4.6 |
| Price | Free | Free |
| Downloads | 100M+ | 100M+ |
| Size | ||
| In-App Purchases 💸 | ||
| Requires Internet | ||
| Age Rating | Everyone | Teen |
| Developer | MyFitnessPal, Inc. | Strava Inc. |
By our entirely fabricated metrics, MyFitnessPal wins the race to the bottom of your free time. Strava is the “responsible” choice, in the way that a slightly smaller slice of cake is responsible. There are no winners here. Only documented hours.
Pick Your Poison
Choose MyFitnessPal if...
MyFitnessPal remains a powerful tool for detailed nutrition tracking with an unmatched food database, but recent monetization strategies and buggy updates have alienated loyal users. It's best suited for those willing to pay for Premium to access basic convenience features, while budget-conscious users or those seeking reliable device sync may prefer alternatives like Carb Manager.
Choose Strava if...
Strava remains the gold standard for social fitness tracking and community motivation, making it ideal for runners and cyclists who thrive on peer engagement. However, casual users frustrated by recent technical bugs and the expensive subscription model ($99/year) may find better value in native manufacturer apps like Garmin Connect or Coros. Download it for the excellent free tracking, but look elsewhere if you need reliable wearable syncing or hate aggressive upselling.
Get MyFitnessPal
Get Strava
Every stat above is affectionately invented. The apps are real, the regret is real, the numbers are vibes. “Requires: stable Wi-Fi, poor impulse control, and a willingness to question your life choices at 2 AM.”